Kendall's historic season

Well now we know what it takes to keep Jason Kendall out of the lineup, a torn rotator cuff succeeded where lack of production failed. I suppose a lot of you will think I'm happy given the anti-Kendall stance stance that I adopted the day he signed but I'm not. Only because I wouldn't wish injury on any player but saying that I am happy that we'll be seeing either Brayan Pena or Lucas May everyday for the remainder of the season. I'm not sure how Yost will allocate playing time but if I had to guess I'd say it'll be a 70/30 split with Pena getting the majority. I hope that May plays two or three times a week but I can certainly understand why if he doesn't.

Now about Kendall's 2010 season, since it's over we can begin analyzing it and make no mistake it was bad, historically bad. Only three Royals catchers with at least 400 plate appearances have had worse seasons, two of which had sterling defensive reputations. I honestly believe that if Kendall were above average defensively AND didn't bat one time in the #2 spot fans in KC would've viewed him a lot differently this year. But on to the list:

Rk	Player	OPS+	PA	Year	HR	RBI	SB	BA	OBP	SLG
1	John Wathan	67	469	1983	2	32	28	.245	.289	.314
2	Brent Mayne	68	414	2003	6	36	0	.245	.307	.344
3	Jim Sundberg	69	491	1986	12	42	1	.212	.303	.322
4	Jason Kendall	70	490	2010	0	37	12	.256	.318	.297

Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used

Wathan was actually pretty good the year before, true his OPS+ was 86 but his OBP was .343 and he set a record for catchers with 36 stolen bases. He also threw out 34% of attempted base stealers. Mayne's second tour of duty with KC was a lot like his first, he was a terrible hitter but a premier defender. He actually had three other seasons that were worse than 2003 but they missed my arbitrary 400 PA cutoff. Sundberg was one of the heroes of KC's 1985 playoff and therefore is exempt from any sort of criticism. His 3-run triple in game 7 of the ALCS remains one of the most important at bats in team history. 

 But here's where it gets interesting and where his season becomes historically bad. Since 1901 of the 506 catchers that came to the plate as many times as Kendall (490) only 15 had worse seasons. What's unfortunate is this list is very Royals friendly (or unfriendly, depending on your point of view). Three future Royals (Sundberg, Kendall, Boone), two Royals (Sundberg, Kendall), and a future Royals manager (Pena) make up seven of the seventeen seasons, when it comes to catchers Kansas City definitely has a type.

Rk	Player	OPS+	PA	Year	Tm	HR	RBI	BA	OBP	SLG
1	Brad Ausmus	54	502	2006	HOU	2	39	.230	.308	.285
2	Brad Ausmus	55	509	2003	HOU	4	47	.229	.303	.291
3	Jim Sundberg	55	540	1975	TEX	6	36	.199	.283	.256
4	Luke Sewell	55	499	1926	CLE	0	46	.238	.302	.293
5	Joe Girardi	58	506	1995	COL	8	55	.262	.308	.359
6	Carlton Fisk	60	491	1986	CHW	14	63	.221	.263	.337
7	Jason Kendall	62	514	2007	TOT	3	41	.242	.301	.309
8	Bob Boone	63	503	1986	CAL	7	49	.222	.287	.305
9	Red Dooin	65	510	1909	PHI	2	38	.224	.264	.271
10	Tony Pena	66	512	1991	BOS	5	48	.231	.291	.321
11	Luke Sewell	66	509	1936	CHW	5	73	.251	.332	.350
12	Michael Barrett	68	506	2001	MON	6	38	.250	.289	.367
13	Jim Sundberg	69	491	1986	KCR	12	42	.212	.303	.322
14	Johnny Edwards	69	515	1970	HOU	7	49	.221	.299	.319
15	Jim Hegan	69	529	1949	CLE	8	55	.224	.298	.338
16	Jason Kendall	70	490	2010	KCR	0	37	.256	.318	.297
17	Bob Boone	70	541	1974	PHI	3	52	.242	.295	.322

Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used

I'm sure people will be tempted to blame Kendall's lack of production on his injury but compare his numbers from the last three years to this one and you'll find they are remarkably similar.
07-09 - .243/.320/.313/69 OPS+
2010 - .256/.318/.297/70 OPS+

What's more likely is that this is just who he is, an aging catcher that has caught far too many games and is nearing the end of his career.